Why Not To Get A German Shepherd: 10 Reasons

“Considering adding a German Shepherd to your family? While these majestic dogs are beloved for their loyalty, intelligence, and versatility, it’s essential to understand that owning a German Shepherd comes with its own set of challenges and responsibilities.

In this blog post, we’ll delve into ten compelling reasons why getting a German Shepherd may not be the right choice for everyone. From their high-energy nature to potential health issues, we’ll explore the various factors that prospective owners should carefully consider before welcoming a German Shepherd into their lives.

Whether you’re a first-time dog owner or a seasoned enthusiast, understanding these reasons can help you make an informed decision and ensure that both you and your future canine companion thrive together.


Why Not To Get A German Shepherd: 10 Reasons

Before diving into the world of German Shepherds, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons to make an informed decision. While these dogs are admired for their intelligence and loyalty, there are several factors to consider before bringing one into your home. Let’s explore ten reasons why getting a German Shepherd may not be the best choice for everyone.


1. High-Energy

German Shepherds are known for their boundless energy and athleticism, which require ample outlets for physical exercise and mental stimulation.

This energy can manifest without appropriate outlets in destructive behaviors such as excessive chewing, digging, or barking.

Consequently, individuals or families with sedentary lifestyles or limited time to dedicate to exercise may find it challenging to meet the needs of a German Shepherd.

Moreover, their high energy levels make them unsuitable for apartment living unless they are provided with regular opportunities for vigorous exercise.

Potential owners should be prepared to commit to daily walks, play sessions, and activities such as obedience training or agility courses to ensure the physical and mental well-being of the German Shepherd.

Failure to adequately address their energy needs can result in frustration for both the owner and the dog, leading to behavioral issues and a strained relationship.

Therefore, opting for a breed with lower energy levels might be more suitable for those unable to accommodate their high-energy requirements.


2. Space Requirements

German Shepherds are large, active dogs that thrive in environments where they have ample room to move around and explore. Due to their size and energetic nature, they are not well-suited for small living spaces like apartments or condos.

Without sufficient space to roam and exercise, German Shepherds may become restless, anxious, or develop behavioral problems.

Additionally, their need for space extends beyond indoor living arrangements; they also require access to a secure outdoor area where they can run, play, and expend their energy.

Potential owners must have a fenced yard or access to nearby parks where their German Shepherd can engage in regular physical activity.

Failing to provide adequate space for a German Shepherd can lead to boredom, frustration, and potentially destructive behavior.

Therefore, individuals or families living in compact or urban environments may want to reconsider getting a German Shepherd and opt for a smaller breed better suited to their living situation.


3. Shedding

German Shepherds are notorious for their heavy shedding, which occurs year-round but typically increases during seasonal changes.

Their double coat consists of a dense undercoat and a longer outer coat, designed to protect them from harsh weather conditions.

While this coat is advantageous for the breed’s outdoor activities and provides insulation, it also means that German Shepherds shed profusely.

Owners can expect to find dog hair throughout their homes, on furniture, clothing, and floors, requiring frequent vacuuming and grooming to manage.

Additionally, individuals with allergies may find living with a German Shepherd challenging due to their shedding. Regular grooming, including brushing several times a week, can help minimize shedding and keep the coat healthy.

However, for those who are sensitive to dog hair or prefer a low-maintenance grooming routine, the constant shedding of a German Shepherd may be a significant deterrent.

Therefore, potential owners should carefully consider their tolerance for shedding and willingness to invest time and effort into managing it before bringing a German Shepherd into their home.


4. Training Needs

German Shepherds are highly intelligent and have a strong desire to please their owners, making them highly trainable. However, their intelligence also means they require consistent and structured training to channel their energy positively and prevent behavioral issues.

Without proper training and socialization from an early age, German Shepherds may exhibit undesirable behaviors such as excessive barking, aggression, or destructive tendencies.

Additionally, their protective instincts can lead to guarding behaviors if not appropriately managed through training. Training a German Shepherd requires time, patience, and dedication, as they thrive on mental stimulation and challenges.

Owners must be prepared to invest in obedience training, leash manners, and socialization with other dogs and people to ensure their German Shepherd becomes a well-behaved companion.

For individuals or families with limited time, experience, or commitment to training, the intensive training needs of a German Shepherd may pose a challenge.

Consequently, those seeking a low-maintenance pet may want to reconsider getting a German Shepherd and opt for a breed with fewer training demands.


5. Protectiveness

German Shepherds are renowned for their loyalty and instinct to protect their families and territory. While this protective nature can provide a sense of security, it can also lead to challenges, particularly in certain situations.

Without proper socialization and training, German Shepherds may exhibit overprotective behaviors, such as excessive barking, growling, or even aggression towards strangers or other animals.

Additionally, their strong guarding instincts may manifest as territorial behavior, making introductions to new people or environments more challenging.

While their protectiveness can be managed through training and socialization, it requires a committed and experienced owner who understands how to channel this trait appropriately.

For individuals or families seeking a more laid-back or easily adaptable pet, the inherent protectiveness of a German Shepherd may pose challenges.

Therefore, potential owners should carefully consider their ability to manage and train a dog with such strong protective instincts before deciding to bring a German Shepherd into their home.


6. Health Issues

While German Shepherds are generally robust dogs, they are predisposed to certain health problems that potential owners should be aware of.

One common health issue in German Shepherds is hip dysplasia, a genetic condition where the hip joint doesn’t develop properly, leading to pain, lameness, and arthritis.

Additionally, they are prone to elbow dysplasia, degenerative myelopathy, and bloat. These health concerns can lead to significant medical expenses, as well as emotional distress for both the dog and their owner.

Furthermore, German Shepherds have a relatively short lifespan compared to some other breeds, typically around 9-13 years, which means owners may have to cope with the loss of their beloved pet sooner than expected.

While responsible breeding practices can help mitigate some of these health risks, potential owners should be prepared for the possibility of dealing with health issues throughout their German Shepherd’s life.

Therefore, individuals considering getting a German Shepherd should carefully research the breed’s common health problems and be prepared to provide the necessary medical care and attention to ensure their pet’s well-being.


7. Financial Responsibility

The costs associated with owning and caring for a German Shepherd can quickly add up, making it a significant investment.

Initially, acquiring a German Shepherd puppy from a reputable breeder or even an amateur breeder can cost anywhere from $500 to $1,000.

Additionally, annual veterinary checkups can range from $50 to $100, with potential additional expenses of $400 to $600 for diagnostic tests if your dog falls ill and emergency vet visits costing at least $1,000.

Vaccinations for a puppy’s first year can amount to $200 to $300, while spaying or neutering may cost between $300 to $1,000.

Furthermore, ongoing expenses such as dog food, treats, supplements, toys, flea and tick preventatives, grooming, and licensing fees can total hundreds of dollars annually.

Long-haired German Shepherds may require grooming sessions costing $75 each, along with grooming products costing $30 to $60 yearly to manage shedding.

Additionally, owners may need to budget for pet insurance, training classes, boarding fees, or dog walkers, adding further financial responsibilities.

Considering these expenses, individuals should carefully assess their budget and willingness to commit to the financial obligations of owning a German Shepherd before deciding to bring one into their home.


8. Separation Anxiety

These dogs are known for their strong bond with their owners and their tendency to become deeply attached to their family members. While this loyalty is admirable, it can also manifest in separation anxiety when left alone for extended periods.

German Shepherds may exhibit distressing behaviors such as incessant barking, destructive chewing, or attempts to escape in response to being separated from their owners.

This can not only be distressing for the dog but also for the owner who may return home to find their belongings damaged or their neighbors complaining about excessive noise.

Managing separation anxiety in German Shepherds requires patience, training, and often the assistance of a professional behaviorist.

Potential owners should consider their lifestyle and whether they can provide the time and attention necessary to prevent or address separation anxiety in a German Shepherd.

For individuals with demanding schedules or those who must leave their dog alone for long periods regularly, a German Shepherd’s susceptibility to separation anxiety may pose significant challenges, making them a less suitable choice of pet.


9. Prey Drive

These dogs have a strong instinctual prey drive, stemming from their history as herding and working dogs. While this trait was essential for their original purpose, it can present challenges in a domestic setting.

German Shepherds may exhibit behaviors such as chasing small animals, including cats or small dogs, or even displaying predatory behavior towards smaller pets in the household.

Additionally, their prey drive can make it difficult to trust them off-leash in environments with wildlife or small animals. Even with training and socialization, their innate drive to chase and capture prey can be difficult to overcome.

Potential owners should carefully consider whether they can manage and mitigate this prey drive, especially if they have other pets or live in areas with abundant wildlife.

For individuals seeking a more relaxed or predictable pet, the strong prey drive of a German Shepherd may be a reason to explore other breeds better suited to their preferences and circumstances.


10. Noise Sensitivity

While German Shepherds are known for their intelligence and loyalty, they can also be sensitive to loud or sudden noises.

This sensitivity can manifest in various ways, including anxiety, fear, or even aggression in response to loud noises such as thunderstorms, fireworks, or even household appliances.

This trait is particularly relevant for individuals living in urban areas where loud noises are commonplace. Without proper training and desensitization techniques, noise sensitivity can lead to significant stress for both the dog and its owners.

Additionally, noise-sensitive German Shepherds may exhibit destructive behaviors or attempt to escape in their efforts to avoid perceived threats from loud noises.

Potential owners should be prepared to provide a calm and secure environment for their German Shepherd, as well as invest time and effort into training and desensitization to help them cope with noise sensitivity.

For individuals or families who are sensitive to noise themselves or live in environments with frequent loud disturbances, the noise sensitivity of a German Shepherd may pose challenges that make them a less suitable choice of pet.


Key Takeaways

While German Shepherds undoubtedly possess many admirable qualities, it’s essential to recognize that they may not be the ideal companions for everyone.

From their high energy levels and space requirements to potential health issues and grooming needs, owning a German Shepherd demands careful consideration and commitment.

By understanding these ten reasons why getting a German Shepherd may not be suitable for everyone, prospective owners can make a well-informed decision that prioritizes the well-being of both themselves and their future canine companion.

Ultimately, whether you decide to welcome a German Shepherd into your life or explore other breeds, it’s crucial to choose a pet that aligns with your lifestyle, resources, and ability to provide the care and attention they deserve.


Why Not To Get A German Shepherd: FAQ


FAQ 1: Are German Shepherds suitable for apartment living?

Answer: German Shepherds are not typically well-suited for apartment living due to their large size and high energy levels. These dogs thrive in environments where they have ample space to move around and expend their energy.

Without access to a yard or regular opportunities for exercise, German Shepherds may become restless, anxious, or exhibit destructive behaviors. Additionally, their tendency to bark can be disruptive to neighbors in close quarters. While it’s not impossible to keep a German Shepherd in an apartment, it requires a dedicated owner willing to provide ample exercise and mental stimulation to meet their needs.


FAQ 2: Are German Shepherds good with children?

Answer: German Shepherds can be excellent family dogs, but their suitability with children depends on various factors such as socialization, training, and the individual dog’s temperament. When properly trained and socialized from a young age, German Shepherds can be gentle, patient, and protective companions for children.

However, due to their large size and energetic nature, they may accidentally knock over small children or play too rough if not supervised. It’s essential for parents to teach children how to interact safely and respectfully with their dogs and to supervise all interactions between them to prevent any potential accidents.


FAQ 3: Do German Shepherds have health issues?

Answer: Like all dog breeds, German Shepherds are prone to certain health issues that potential owners should be aware of. Common health problems in German Shepherds include hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, degenerative myelopathy, bloat, and skin allergies.

Additionally, they may be susceptible to genetic conditions such as hemophilia and exocrine pancreatic insufficiency. While responsible breeding practices can help reduce the risk of inherited disorders, prospective owners should be prepared for potential medical expenses associated with treating and managing these health issues throughout their dog’s life.


FAQ 4: Do German Shepherds require a lot of grooming?

Answer: German Shepherds have a dense double coat that requires regular grooming to keep it healthy and manageable. While they do shed moderately year-round, their shedding increases seasonally, requiring more frequent brushing during these times to remove loose hair and prevent matting.

Additionally, German Shepherds may benefit from occasional baths to keep their coat clean and reduce shedding. Owners should also trim their dog’s nails regularly, clean their ears, and brush their teeth to maintain overall hygiene.

While grooming requirements may vary depending on the individual dog’s coat type and activity level, potential owners should be prepared to dedicate time and effort to regular grooming to keep their German Shepherd looking and feeling their best.



You May Also Like

Boxer vs German Shepherd: Comprehensive Comparison

Border Collie vs German Shepherd: Comprehensive Comparison

Can A German Shepherd Kill A Wolf?

German Shepherd vs Mountain Lion: Can A German Shepherd Kill A Mountain Lion?


Leave a Comment