Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Comprehensive Comparison

In the world of large and lovable dog breeds, the Great Pyrenees and the Saint Bernard stand out as magnificent giants, each possessing their own unique qualities and characteristics. When it comes to choosing a canine companion, especially if you’re looking for a larger breed, understanding the differences and similarities between these two remarkable dogs is essential.

In this “Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Comprehensive Comparison”, we will delve into the world of the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernard, exploring everything from their physical attributes and temperaments to their grooming needs and health considerations. Whether you’re seeking a loyal family pet or a diligent working dog, this guide will help you make an informed decision as we bring these two gentle giants face to face, highlighting their pros and cons in various aspects of their lives. So, if you’re torn between the majestic Great Pyrenees and the affectionate Saint Bernard, read on to discover which of these magnificent breeds may be your perfect match.

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Size and Physical Characteristics

Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards are both imposing, large dog breeds known for their gentle nature and remarkable size. In this comparison, we’ll delve into their size and physical characteristics, highlighting the distinctions between these two magnificent breeds.

Great Pyrenees:

Size: Great Pyrenees, true to their name, are indeed great in size. These dogs are known for their impressive stature, with adult males typically standing between 27 to 32 inches (68 to 81 cm) at the shoulder, while adult females are slightly smaller, ranging from 25 to 29 inches (64 to 74 cm).

Weight: In addition to their considerable height, Great Pyrenees are heavy dogs. Adult males usually weigh between 100 to 160 pounds (45 to 73 kg), while adult females typically weigh between 85 to 115 pounds (39 to 52 kg).

Coat: Great Pyrenees have a thick double coat designed to keep them warm in cold climates. Their coat is primarily white, sometimes featuring markings of gray, tan, or badger, often concentrated around the ears and eyes.

Tail: They sport a plume-like tail that gracefully arches over their back, adding to their majestic appearance.

Appearance: Great Pyrenees are known for their noble and majestic appearance. They possess a strong, muscular build and a face often described as “gentle” and expressive.

 

Saint Bernard:

Size: Saint Bernards are another massive breed, known for their substantial size. Adult males generally reach heights between 28 to 30 inches (71 to 76 cm), while adult females range from 26 to 28 inches (66 to 71 cm).

Weight: These dogs are true giants, with adult males typically weighing between 140 to 180 pounds (64 to 82 kg), and adult females weighing around 120 to 140 pounds (54 to 64 kg). Some Saint Bernards may even exceed these weight ranges.

Coat: Saint Bernards have a dense, thick, and water-resistant double coat. Their coat is primarily white with markings of red, brindle, tan, and sometimes darker shades around the ears and face.

Tail: They have a broad tail that is moderately long, often carried low, in a relaxed manner.

Appearance: Saint Bernards are renowned for their gentle and kindly expression. They possess a strong, massive, and powerful build, emphasizing their role as working dogs and rescue animals in alpine regions.

Great Pyrenees tend to be slightly taller and less heavy compared to Saint Bernard’s. The latter, famous for their rescuing abilities in the Swiss Alps, are characterized by their dense and water-resistant coat and impressively robust build. Understanding these physical distinctions is essential when considering which of these magnificent breeds is the best fit for your home and lifestyle.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Temperament and Personality

When comparing the temperament and personality of Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards, you’ll find that both breeds are known for their gentle and kind nature, but they exhibit distinct characteristics that are influenced by their history and purpose.

Great Pyrenees:

Gentle and Calm: Great Pyrenees are often described as gentle giants. They have a calm and even-tempered disposition, which makes them highly suitable as family pets.

Protective: These dogs are known for their protective instincts. They have a natural inclination to guard and protect their family, whether that includes humans or other animals.

Independent Thinkers: The great Pyrenees are intelligent but can also be independent thinkers. They are not always quick to respond to commands, and their decision-making may take precedence in certain situations.

Aloof with Strangers: They tend to be reserved and somewhat aloof around strangers. This natural wariness makes them effective watchdogs, but it requires early socialization to prevent excessive shyness or fearfulness.

Low Energy: Great Pyrenees are not highly active dogs. They are content with moderate exercise and can even be a bit lazy at times. Their laid-back nature suits families with a more relaxed lifestyle.

 

Saint Bernard:

Gentle and Affectionate: Saint Bernards are renowned for their gentle and affectionate nature. They are known as “gentle giants” as well and are particularly good with children, making them excellent family pets.

Good with People: They tend to be sociable and friendly with people, including strangers. Their friendly demeanor often means they are less effective as watchdogs compared to Great Pyrenees.

Easygoing: Saint Bernards are generally easygoing and have a relaxed personality. They are well-suited for families that prefer a dog with a calm demeanor.

Protective Instincts: While they can be protective, their protective instincts are typically less pronounced than those of the Great Pyrenees. They are less likely to exhibit excessive guarding behavior.

Moderate Energy: Saint Bernards have moderate energy levels and require daily exercise to keep them fit and mentally stimulated. They enjoy leisurely walks and playtime.

The great Pyrenees are more protective and independent, making them excellent watchdogs, while Saint Bernards are generally more sociable and easygoing, often considered more affectionate and suitable for families. Your choice between these two breeds should align with your lifestyle, whether you prefer the protective instincts of the Great Pyrenees or the friendly and easygoing temperament of Saint Bernards.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Grooming Needs

Great Pyrenees have a thick double coat that necessitates regular brushing, especially during seasonal shedding, to prevent matting and reduce loose fur around the house. They are known for their heavy shedding, particularly during changes in the seasons. This breed’s grooming demands are relatively high, requiring consistent care to maintain their coat and overall hygiene.

On the other hand, Saint Bernards have a dense, thick, and water-resistant double coat that is also prone to shedding, but it tends to be less intensive compared to the Great Pyrenees. Regular brushing can help manage shedding, but it’s not as demanding as with Great Pyrenees. Both breeds require occasional baths and routine maintenance of their ears, eyes, and nails. In summary, if you’re seeking a breed with lower maintenance grooming needs, Saint Bernards are generally more manageable compared to Great Pyrenees, which require more time and effort in terms of grooming to keep them looking their best and to manage shedding.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Lifespan

Both the Great Pyrenees and the Saint Bernard are large, lovable breeds with lifespans that typically range from 7 to 10 years. However, various factors, including genetics, diet, exercise, and overall healthcare, play a crucial role in determining the actual lifespan of an individual dog. Providing them with proper nutrition, regular exercise, routine veterinary care, and a safe, loving environment can significantly contribute to a longer and healthier life for both Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Good with kids

Great Pyrenees, with their calm and protective disposition, are known for their patience, making them excellent family dogs. Their natural inclination to watch over their family extends to the youngest members, making them reliable companions for children. These gentle giants often act as natural caregivers and protectors, fostering a sense of security within a family environment.

Saint Bernards share a similar reputation for being good with kids, earning them the affectionate nickname of “gentle giants” as well. They are known for their friendly and easygoing demeanor, which makes them particularly well-suited for families. Their affectionate and sociable nature means they often form strong bonds with children, and their relaxed disposition provides a sense of comfort to kids who prefer a less excitable and more laid-back canine companion.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Trainability

The great Pyrenees, known for their intelligence, can sometimes be independent thinkers, which can present training challenges. Their protective nature can also lead to them making their own decisions, so patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement-based training methods are essential. Early socialization is particularly crucial to ensure they are well-behaved around other dogs and people.

On the other hand, Saint Bernards are generally more obedient and responsive to training. Their strong work ethic, friendly disposition, and eagerness to please make them quick learners. While they might be more “obedient” compared to the Great Pyrenees, they still benefit from early socialization to ensure that their protective instincts are well-balanced.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Exercise needs

Great Pyrenees are relatively low-energy dogs and are content with moderate exercise, such as daily walks and playtime in the yard. Their calm demeanor and laid-back nature make them a good match for families with a more relaxed lifestyle, as they are not as demanding in terms of physical activity.

In contrast, Saint Bernards have moderate energy levels and require more exercise to stay happy and healthy. They enjoy longer walks, vigorous play, and activities that challenge their intelligence. Providing sufficient exercise is vital to prevent boredom and potential behavioral issues in this breed. Therefore, it’s essential to assess your own activity level and living situation to determine which breed’s exercise needs align best with your lifestyle and your ability to keep them physically and mentally engaged.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Dog behavior issues

Both Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards, with their protective instincts and strong guarding behaviors, can occasionally encounter certain behavior issues if not properly managed and trained. These issues are more a result of their natural tendencies than inherent aggressiveness, but they do require careful handling:

Great Pyrenees:

Excessive Barking: Great Pyrenees are vocal dogs and may bark excessively, particularly when they perceive potential threats. This tendency can be managed with training and socialization.

Stubbornness: Their independent nature may make them appear stubborn in training. Consistent and patient training methods are essential to overcome this.

Territorial Aggression: Great Pyrenees are naturally territorial, which can sometimes lead to aggressive behavior towards strangers or other animals entering their perceived territory. Proper socialization is critical to manage this.

Roaming: They have a tendency to roam if not securely contained. Their protective instincts can drive them to patrol larger areas.

 

Saint Bernard:

Protective Aggression: While their protective nature is a desirable trait, it can lead to aggression if not properly socialized and trained. They may be wary of strangers and may react aggressively if they perceive a threat.

Independence: Their independence can sometimes make them less responsive to commands, especially if they believe they know better. Consistent training and positive reinforcement are essential to ensure they respond well.

Territorial Behavior: Like Great Pyrenees, Saint Bernards can exhibit territorial behavior, which can lead to aggression towards intruders or unfamiliar animals.

Destructive Behavior: If not mentally and physically stimulated, Saint Bernards may resort to destructive behaviors as a way to release pent-up energy.

Both breeds require early socialization and consistent, positive reinforcement training to manage these potential behavior issues. It’s crucial for owners to understand and respect their guarding instincts while ensuring that they are well-mannered and controlled in various situations. Professional training and guidance can be particularly beneficial, given their independent nature and strong guarding instincts.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Intelligence

Great Pyrenees are known for their intelligence and their ability to assess situations in a calm and deliberate manner. They are independent thinkers and may make decisions based on their own judgment. While this independence can sometimes make them appear less obedient, they are capable of learning and problem-solving, often making deliberate choices based on their assessment of a situation.

On the other hand, Saint Bernards are also intelligent but tend to be more responsive to training. Their strong work ethic and eagerness to please make them quick learners who often excel in tasks that require problem-solving and decision-making. They are generally more “obedient” compared to the Great Pyrenees, as they readily respond to commands and tasks, thanks to their loyalty and cooperative nature. Ultimately, the intelligence of both breeds can shine when matched with the right training approach, with Great Pyrenees showcasing thoughtful, independent intelligence and Saint Bernards demonstrating eager and cooperative problem-solving abilities.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Good with other dogs

Great Pyrenees, as guardian dogs, often exhibit a natural protective instinct, which can lead to them being reserved or cautious around unfamiliar dogs, particularly in situations where they perceive a potential threat. Early and consistent socialization is essential to ensure they are well-behaved and comfortable around other dogs, particularly in multi-dog households.

Saint Bernards, while also protective to some extent, generally have a more adaptable and relaxed attitude toward other dogs when properly socialized from a young age. They are often more accepting of new canine companions, especially when introduced gradually and in a positive environment.

In both cases, careful introduction and socialization play a significant role in determining how well they interact with other dogs. Supervision is essential, and it’s vital to monitor their behavior to prevent conflicts, especially in situations where there may be resource guarding or territorial concerns.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Companion dogs

Great Pyrenees are known for their calm and gentle nature, which makes them comforting and reassuring companions in a family setting. Their protective instincts, patience, and natural inclination to watch over their loved ones, including children, make them excellent choices for families looking for a dependable and protective dog.

Saint Bernards, on the other hand, are celebrated for their friendly and easygoing disposition, earning them the nickname “gentle giants.” Their sociable and affectionate nature makes them wonderful companions who form strong bonds with their owners and are especially well-suited for families seeking a more laid-back and loving canine friend. While they are also protective to some extent, their friendly and easygoing nature often makes them a delightful choice for households that value warmth, sociability, and affection in a companion dog. In either case, both breeds offer unwavering loyalty and affection when raised and trained properly, adding warmth and companionship to their owners’ lives.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Health Issues

Great Pyrenees are known to be prone to hip and elbow dysplasia, which affects their joint health. They also have a higher risk of bloat, a life-threatening condition where the stomach twists upon itself. Other health issues that can affect them include entropion, a condition involving the inward folding of the eyelids, and various types of cancer. Additionally, some Great Pyrenees may experience heart problems and dental problems. Responsible breeding practices, regular veterinary check-ups, a balanced diet, and appropriate exercise can help mitigate these health concerns and ensure a long and healthy life for these dogs.

Similarly, Saint Bernards are susceptible to hip and elbow dysplasia, as well as the risk of bloat, entropion, and heart issues. Due to their hearty appetites, obesity can also be a concern, which can exacerbate other health problems. Some individuals may experience respiratory difficulties due to their short muzzles. While not all Saint Bernards will encounter these issues, responsible ownership, regular veterinary care, proper nutrition, and exercise are key to maintaining their well-being and ensuring they live happy and healthy lives.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Pros & Cons

Great Pyrenees: Pros

Gentle Giants: Great Pyrenees are known for their gentle and calm nature, making them excellent family pets.

Protective: They are highly protective, making them effective watchdogs and livestock guardians.

Loyal: Great Pyrenees are extremely loyal to their families and are known for forming strong bonds with their owners.

Cold Weather Tolerance: Their thick double coat makes them well-suited for cold climates.

Good with Children: They are usually good with children, being patient and gentle.

 

Great Pyrenees: Cons

Independence: They can be independent thinkers and may require consistent training and socialization.

Heavy Shedding: They shed a lot, especially during seasonal changes, which can be a downside for those who dislike dog hair.

Size: Their large size can be a disadvantage in small living spaces.

Barking: They tend to be vocal, which can be a nuisance in quiet neighborhoods.

Health Issues: They are prone to certain health issues, which can lead to costly vet bills.

 

Saint Bernard: Pros

Gentle and Affectionate: Saint Bernards are known for their gentle and affectionate nature, making them excellent family pets.

Good with People: They tend to be sociable and friendly with people, including strangers.

Easygoing: Saint Bernards are generally easygoing and have a relaxed personality.

Protective Instincts: While they can be protective, their protective instincts are typically less pronounced than those of the Great Pyrenees.

Moderate Energy: Saint Bernards have moderate energy levels, requiring daily exercise to keep them fit and mentally stimulated.

 

Saint Bernard: Cons

Heavy Shedding: They also shed quite a bit, particularly during seasonal changes.

Independence: They may be less responsive to commands due to their independent nature.

Size: Their large size can be a challenge in small living spaces.

Health Issues: Like Great Pyrenees, they are susceptible to certain health problems, requiring responsible ownership and regular vet care.

Drooling: They are known for their drooling, which can be a downside for those who are particular about cleanliness.

The choice between these two breeds should depend on your specific needs, living situation, and your ability to provide the necessary training, grooming, and exercise. Both breeds can make wonderful companions, but it’s important to be aware of their characteristics and consider how they align with your lifestyle and preferences.

 

Key Takeaways

The comparison of the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernard offers valuable insights into these magnificent giants of the dog world. Whether you’re searching for a loyal family pet or a diligent working dog, understanding their unique characteristics is essential.

Great Pyrenees impress with their majestic appearance, protective instincts, and calm nature. They are independent thinkers and excel as watchdogs. However, their independent nature can make training and grooming a bit more demanding. On the other hand, Saint Bernards, also known as gentle giants, are renowned for their affectionate and sociable demeanor. They are ideal for families seeking a loving and easygoing companion, although their size and grooming needs should be considered.

Ultimately, the choice between a Great Pyrenees and a Saint Bernard should align with your lifestyle, living situation, and ability to meet their specific needs. Both breeds offer warmth, loyalty, and companionship, making them wonderful additions to any dog-loving household. So, whether you’re drawn to the noble and independent nature of the Great Pyrenees or the friendly and sociable disposition of Saint Bernards, you’ll be sure to find a steadfast and lovable companion in either of these majestic giants.

 

Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: FAQ

1. Which breed is larger, the Great Pyrenees or the Saint Bernard?

Great Pyrenees are slightly taller on average, but Saint Bernards tend to be heavier and more massive. Great Pyrenees males typically stand at 27 to 32 inches (68 to 81 cm) at the shoulder, while Saint Bernard males range from 28 to 30 inches (71 to 76 cm). In terms of weight, Great Pyrenees males usually weigh between 100 to 160 pounds (45 to 73 kg), whereas Saint Bernard males weigh around 140 to 180 pounds (64 to 82 kg).

2. Are the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards good with children?

Both breeds are known for their gentle and patient nature, which makes them excellent companions for families with children. Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards are often referred to as “gentle giants” and tend to be protective and loving toward kids.

3. How do the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards compare in terms of grooming needs?

Great Pyrenees have a thick double coat that requires frequent brushing to manage shedding, especially during seasonal changes. Their grooming needs are relatively high. On the other hand, Saint Bernards also have a dense double coat that requires regular brushing but tends to be less intensive in terms of shedding compared to Great Pyrenees. Saint Bernards are generally more manageable when it comes to grooming.

4. What is the average lifespan of a Great Pyrenees and a Saint Bernard?

Both Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards have an average lifespan of 7 to 10 years. However, individual lifespans can vary depending on factors such as genetics, diet, exercise, and healthcare.

5. Which breed is more obedient and easier to train, the Great Pyrenees or the Saint Bernard?

Saint Bernards are generally more obedient and responsive to training due to their cooperative nature and eagerness to please. Great Pyrenees can be more independent thinkers and may require patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement-based training methods.

6. Do the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards get along with other dogs?

Both breeds can get along with other dogs when properly socialized. However, Great Pyrenees, with their protective instincts, may be reserved or cautious around unfamiliar dogs. Saint Bernards tend to be more adaptable and sociable when introduced gradually and positively to other canines.

7. Which breed is better suited for cold climates?

Both the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards are well-suited for cold climates due to their thick double coats and large size. They can handle low temperatures, but it’s essential to provide them with proper shelter and warmth during extreme cold.

8. What are the common health issues associated with Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards?

Both breeds are prone to certain health issues, including hip and elbow dysplasia, bloat, and heart problems. Great Pyrenees may also experience entropion and various types of cancer. Saint Bernards can be at risk for obesity due to their hearty appetites and may experience respiratory difficulties because of their short muzzles.

9. Do the Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards drool excessively?

Saint Bernards are known for drooling more compared to Great Pyrenees. This is an important consideration for individuals who are particular about cleanliness and prefer less drool.

10. Which breed is more suitable for families seeking a protective dog?

Both Great Pyrenees and Saint Bernards are excellent choices for families looking for protective dogs. They are known for their loyalty, patience, and protective instincts, which make them natural guardians of their loved ones.

 

You May Also Like

When Do Great Pyrenees Go Into Heat? All You Need To Know

Great Dane vs Doberman: Comprehensive Comparison

Great Dane vs Rottweiler: Comprehensive Comparison

2 thoughts on “Great Pyrenees vs Saint Bernard: Comprehensive Comparison”

Leave a Comment